Modern romance novels seem to often feature smart, capable female protagonists navigating social complexities including friendships, careers, and partnerships, succeeding in the end in many of their goals; these are mostly read by women (one poll put male readership at 18%). Men seem to often be portrayed as unrealistically manipulable, self-contradictory, and/or unable or unwilling to understand or manage their emotions. Recent fiction designed mainly for men seems to often emphasize actual or threatened violence, as by military personnel or first responders, or crime detection, but with less attention to advancement via social skill (though it seems obvious that social savvy is much more useful than inclination to violence in reality). Without including unrealistic or belittling portrayals for any group, what is the equivalent of the romance genre that includes the positive themes of self-improvement, social cleverness, and connection, outside of violent contexts, and is aimed at a male audience, with mainly male protagonists? The closest thing that comes to mind is the Victorian rags-to-riches genre (by eg. Horatio Alger) including males improving their stations through hard work, morality, and smarts, but this too seems out of touch with reality. I am not necessarily looking for Romance, just its equivalent, with a high-EQ hero achieving goals without beating people up, as least not very often.
by GrantTB
4 Comments
Good romance. Seriously. Poorly written romance renders the male characters 2 dimensionally. Well written books portray characters that develop themselves as the story progresses. And do not mistake popular romance or “intellectual” romance for good writing.
I disagree with your characterization of men in romance novels.
Are you open to genre fiction? I find the portrayal of men in Sci-Fi & Fantasy (yes, even fantasy romance) can be a bit more nuanced than just “big man is strong, fights”
The Expanse series features a large cast of characters across the books that have different strengths, navigate well through political & social situations. The interpersonal relationships and complicated character backgrounds are the best part of the series for me.
Weirdly, Ali Hazelwood’s Bride has a great Male Lead, but it’s the only book of hers that I’ve read. And I find that Sarah J Maas, despite creating a few of the defining the “shadow daddy” characters in the genre actually writes pretty nuanced Male characters with complex back stories & social relationships. Particularly in Throne of Glass & Crescent City, even if her female characters are centered in the plot.
I don’t know that you can make a statement that an entire genre writes men a certain way, I don’t think that’s true.
Are you looking for romance novels or fiction in general that has positive male role models?