Charmed/Vampire Diaries Read-alike

Hi everyone!

I’m looking for a book that has the same vibe as The Vampire Diaries TV show and the OG Charmed show. I have really been on a cozy small town paranormal 90’s whimsigoth kick recently and am looking for some suggestions to scratch the itch.

I don’t really want to read YA titles but if one really fits the bill I am more than willing to give it a shot. I just want a moody book, with cozy spooky paranormal stuff. I love witches and vampires.

I have tried True Blood but the plot was way too slow for me and I had to stop listening to it (the audiobook narrator is awesome, I just got bored). I would love something along those lines but with a faster pace or higher stakes.

Thanks!