November 2025
    M T W T F S S
     12
    3456789
    10111213141516
    17181920212223
    24252627282930

    Hi, I am thinking of picking up a big read and it ultimately came down to the titular two books. I plan to read both, but I want advice on which to read first. I would prefer the one I read first to be a little easier to read, but it is not a hard preference. My last big read was McDuff's Crime and Punishment, which was not that difficult to read.

    I also need advice on which translations to prefer for both, I'm considering Edith Grossman's and John Rutherford's translations for Don Quixote, and I think Robin Buss's is the preferred one for The Count of Monte Cristo, but I am also considering Peter Washington's translation.

    by Anokata22

    2 Comments

    1. Terrible_Rutabaga442 on

      I’d start with Monte Cristo. It’s way easier to get into and moves faster. The Buss translation reads super smooth.
      Don Quixote is great too, just a bit slower, and Grossman’s version is the one I’d pick.

    2. Just purchased Don Quixote and it will be my next read. But I can say Count of Monte Cristo is an all timer

    Leave A Reply