Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell is everything I expected Babel and Katabasis to be.

I apologize to all RF Kuang's fans in advance for the post below. Also I'm Italian so please forgive me for clumsy turns of phrases!
I have read both Babel and Katabasis, because the premise is so damn promising for both! First up, I read Babel because, as a translator myself, I felt seen and was so excited to read about a translator protagonist that can make magic by manipulating language! Unfortunately I found the story to be very simplistic and predictable, and the notions of linguistics are taken word for word from the first year linguistics exam. Sigh.
A few years later, and Katabasis came out. A critique of academia and research with a descent to Hell? This time I had low expectations but decided to try because it did seem interesting (and the cover is so beautiful !) And if possible this novel was even more simplistic, the critique was very much in your face and contained every complaint that my PhD friends have had over the years. The story itself, nothing to write home about.

Now I'm reading Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell, it even says in the cover that it's "the book Kuang wishes she had written". Yeah, I can see that. I'm only 300 pages in out of over 800 but this is everything I wanted the other two novels to be and more. The critique of the academia is there but not in your face, the humour is fantastic, the weaving of the fantasy element in a real historical setting is very well done. The plot is not the most original, but everything else is so good that it does not matter much to me.

Now for the possibly controversial part of my thinking. JS and Mr N is mostly considered too dense and boring from what I've seen in social media. Granted it is a slow book, but I wouldn't call it "dense" or particularly intellectual. It reads like a 21st century version of a 19th century novel, which probably was the author's goal. Kuang, in contrast, is hailed as an intellectual read, while for me she just hammers her metaphors in the reader's face with no subtlety and requires no critical thinking whatsoever as she does everything for you on the page. Have we stooped so low as readers that hers are considere the "elevated" books to read?