Suggest me a book as a picky reader trying to get into reading more

I’m trying to get into reading more but I struggle to stick with books, and I find a lot of popular recommendations cringe and difficult to read.

I liked Normal People and My Year of Rest and Relaxation. I enjoy writing that feels natural and smart, not overly filled with modern colloquialisms.

Looking for fiction but also open to non-fiction (maybe even memoirs)? I’m looking for interesting books that pull you in (since it’s easy for me to quit) and teach you about something or help you reflect.

Appreciate any recommendations!!!