April 2026
    M T W T F S S
     12345
    6789101112
    13141516171819
    20212223242526
    27282930  

    PLEASE help me. I haven't got an answer from this I was happy about.

    I am practically moving on from fiction. I love the genre but it is so sad at times.

    Classic literature is almost always sad or satirical, two genres I've grown tired of. And this is to no offence to anyone who likes it, I am just dealing with a LOT and this is NOT for me right now.
    – Death is not sad, untimely deaths are, a la Foundation series, even so, it depends, a la Beowulf
    – Warm doesn't mean it's not sad, a la A man called Ove (he tries to kill himself, and he doesn't but it left me weeping anyway)
    – Violence doesn't mean it's sad, a la Mistborn
    – Non-sensical "nature of man" type sadness that is avoidable is sad, a la Stoner
    – A Gentleman in Moscow is depressing because he is on house arrest
    – A good ending doesn't make the story not depressing, a la One Hundred Years of Solitude
    I literally just want a book in which a character has some struggle, and becomes successful, end story. I know this doesn't make for a good conflict, but I need good books. I don't need YA (I hated Legends and Lattes because I wasn't the audience for it), I need literature. If you have a good fiction suggestion, I would love to hear it too. No satire either.

    I don't know what happened, epics are relatively positive. Beowulf, Odyssey, Aenid, Gilgamesh, even Illiad, or Mahabharat with all its violence, or what have you. Even in modernist times, Henry V, Pymilgian (that GBS play I am forgetting), etc. feel generally fine. King Lear gets a bit depressing etc. But modern works WANT you to be sad, I don't know why. Either sad or coddled. There's no great Arthurian style legends anymore. Did people just lose the lust for life? Does everyone need to humbled? Is everything a slice of life now? In the days of serfs, we had hope, and in the days of hope, we have bleak and despair in our media. Why, I ask.

    Books I've read and find depressing:

    1. Stoner
    2. East of Eden, sometimes
    3. Tortilla Flat
    4. Moby Dick
    5. Absalom, Absalom
    6. Madame Bovary
    7. Anna Karenina
    8. A Farewell to Arms
    9. Anything by that weirdo Nabakov, but I made the mistake of reading Lolita because I listened to reddit
    10. Rushdie's books
    11. Literally any word ever written by Dostoyevsky
    12. Hamlet (love stories are poorly written anyway)
    13. Les Miserables
    14. Flowers for Algernon
    15. Songs for Solomon (still finishing up)
    16. All Quiet on the Western Front

    And many more. There was a time in my life I could read these just fine, I can't anymore. Life is very heavy. Please help.

    by Astraltraumagarden

    5 Comments

    1. Infamous_Wave9878 on

      I feel like I’m not rly clear on what you find sad bc most books explore different emotions so they’ll have sad parts even if the overarching tone is happier

      Books that have a happy overall feeling:

      Anne of Green Gables

      Any Jane Austen

      Remarkably Bright Creatures

      Piranesi is quiet joy and love for the world

      Little women (there is a death tho so idk but it’s overall happy)

      The house of the cerulean sea (prob closest to a literary hug you could find)

      Edit: I have to add this cos it bugged the English degree in me. epics aren’t really comparable to modern classics or literary fiction. They have a completely different purpose and are tied to myth, religion and cultural identity in order to explain life and death the gods etc etc

      Modern fiction is more concerned with emotional truths and identity and meaning instead of mythic resolution

    2. Least_Watch_8803 on

      Looove “The House By The Cerulean Sea” And your description that it feels like a warm hug is right on.

    3. You should definitely be reading Jane Austen, you’re clearly a wide reader if you haven’t tried her yet, you’ll definitely be pleasantly surprised

    4. Least_Watch_8803 on

      Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E Harrow is a Gooorgeously written book whose prose and is so lush and eloquent but not in the where it gets too precious and self-aware. Well crafted, wonderful protagonist. True, it’s not classical literature and I don’t know whether that’s what your restricting yourself to or not. But NPR agreed with me and extolled it’s virtues.

    Leave A Reply