Just finished The Colour Out of Space and yeah, Lovecraft cooked here. The vibes are familiar to me now: weird meteorite, cursed farm, slow-burn cosmic rot creeping into everything like black mold from another dimension. The way the land itself becomes wrong is genuinely unsettling. No tentacle monsters doing backflips, just this quiet, “something is off and it’s only getting worse” dread.
That said… I didn’t love it as much as At the Mountains of Madness.
Colour is creepy in a subtle, insidious way, but Mountains lingers in my brain still. Ancient alien cities, forbidden history, the slow realization that humanity is a cosmic afterthought? That story felt bigger, more unhinged, and more rewarding to piece together. Colour feels more like watching a tragedy unfold from the outside, while Mountains drags you into the nightmare and locks the door behind you.
Also, Lovecraft’s usual “I can’t describe it, it was too indescribable to describe” writing style is in full force here. I get that the horror is supposed to be beyond human comprehension, but at some point it feels like bro just ran out of adjectives and went, “trust me, it was BAD bad.” Still effective though
Overall:
It’s moody, tragic, and quietly horrifying. But if you’re chasing that full-on existential meltdown that Mountains of Madness delivers, The Colour Out of Space might feel more like a creepy appetizer than a main course.
Still glad I read it. Would not move to a farm near any glowing rocks though.
Thank you for all the recommendations and for following me on my Lovecraftian journey. 🖤
by Caffeine_And_Regret
1 Comment
That whole thing about running out of adjectives hit me hard lol, Lovecraft really does lean into the “words cannot express this cosmic wrongness” crutch way too much sometimes. Mountains definitely has that bigger scope that makes you feel like an ant discovering the universe is run by something that doesn’t even notice you exist
Colour’s more like watching your neighbor’s house slowly get consumed by something awful while you’re powerless to help, which is its own kind of horror but yeah not as brain-melting