I’m looking for book / webnovel / manga / even TV recommendations, I will go into detail about what I enjoy, but just to be clear I don't expect a recommendation to fit all of my tastes perfectly and chances are I will enjoy it, even with a majority of things not being according to my preferances
Some favorites
- Mistborn Era 1
- Red Rising
- Kingkiller Chronicle
- Stormlight 1–2
- Lord of the Mysteries
- Mother of Learning
- The Perfect Run
- Shadow Slave
- Super Supportive
The main thing
My biggest preferences are less about genre and more about how the story handles characters, relationships, and important emotional scenes.
Protagonists
I strongly prefer protagonists with offensive intent.
I usually like characters who actively want something and pursue it, such as:
- revenge
- truth
- social ascent
- revolution
- infiltration
- ambition
Darrow from Red Rising and Kvothe from Name of the Wind are great examples for me.
I’m less drawn to protagonists who mainly:
- react to danger
- protect what they already have
- fulfill duty because events force them to
“Real person” vibe
I want worlds that feel like actual people live in them.
I do not need romance-first stories, but I do want:
- attraction
- desire
- intimacy
- sexuality
- emotional vulnerability
to feel like natural parts of life.
I dislike settings that feel emotionally or sexually sterilized.
Important scenes should happen on-page
This is a huge one for me.
I hate when stories skip the most emotionally interesting scene with something like:
- “we talked for hours”
- “I filled them in”
- “later we discussed our plans”
I want to actually see:
- reunions
- confessions
- reveals
- fallout
- debriefs
- relationship-changing conversations
Even if I already know the information as a reader, I still want to watch the characters share it and react to it.
One of the reasons Red Rising #2 Golden Son worked so well for me is scenes like the “bacon and eggs” chapter, that kind of on-page emotional/intimate reckoning is exactly what I want more of.
A very specific pet peeve: withholding important information
I really dislike when one character learns something that obviously matters a lot to another character, and then the story does not let them discuss it even though a real person probably would the next time they meet.
I’m not saying characters can’t keep secrets.
I just want a believable on-page reason for the silence, even if it’s just one sentence of internal thought.
Otherwise I’m left wondering:
- did this conversation happen off-screen?
- are we pretending this wouldn’t come up?
- is the author dodging the scene?
Relationship fallout
I love when major plot events visibly affect:
- trust
- affection
- resentment
- attraction
- loyalty
- distance / closeness between characters
and the story actually lets us watch those changes happen.
Related to that: I really like when characters actually tell each other how plot events made them feel.
Stuff like:
- when you lied to me, it turned my world upside down
- when I thought you died, I couldn’t sleep
- when you left me, I felt abandoned / afraid / furious
- did any of this start as something real, or was I just part of your plan?
It does not need to be healthy communication. It can be angry, messy, accusatory, raw. I just like scenes where the truth and fallout from that truth is spoken aloud.
Multi-POV
This does not have to be multi-POV. Single-POV stories can absolutely work for me.
But when a story is multi-POV, my favorite use of it is when POV characters actually interact and I get both sides of the moment.
What I love is:
- seeing how each misunderstands or reads the other
- seeing what each hides
- seeing how the same scene feels from both interiors
So I care less about “bigger scope” for its own sake and more about cross-interiority and convergence.
What I like less
- protagonists who are mostly reactive / defensive from the start
- important emotional scenes being skipped or summarized
- one character clearly having major information that would matter to another, but the story not dealing with that pressure
- multi-POV stories where non-main POVs stay too detached for too long
- stories that rush past fallout because the plot wants to keep moving
Genre / setting / plot lane
This matters, but less than the character stuff above.
I often like:
- lived-in fantasy or science-fantasy
- hierarchies, factions, institutions, politics, secret societies
- underdog rise / social ascent
- conspiracies, hidden truths, infiltration, mystery
- academy / institution stories
- progression / webnovel energy, as long as the characters still feel like people
Romance note
I often really like stories with one central romantic subplot, but there does not have to be one.
Even just the believable sense that a meaningful romantic connection could emerge is enough for me.
So basically I’m looking for:
- a protagonist who strongly wants something
- strong character / relationship writing
- important scenes actually shown on-page
- a world that feels inhabited by real people
- at least some emotional / romantic possibility
- and ideally, if it’s multi-POV, actual convergence rather than just disconnected scope
Would prefer if recommendations don't explain too much where it fits in with my tastes as that is part of the surprise I don't want spoiled. but if you have a recommendation please write something short about genre, setting and plot
by DeusMachinea
2 Comments
*The blade itself* by Joe Abercrombie
If you like it, there are eight more books, plus short stories.
Also check out *Game of thrones* by George Martin if you haven’t yet. Four more books in that one if you like it, plus prequels.
The Traitor Baru Cormorant – Seth Dickinson – ruthless social climb + political mind games, every convo matters and the fallout hits hard
The Next One Piece (thenextonepiece dot substack dot com) – dystopian into multi-world power struggle, super proactive cast with messy loyalties and lots of on-page confronations I couldn’t stop reading
A Practical Guide to Evil – ErraticErrata – web serial with ambitious protag playing the system, constant scheming and real relationship shifts shown live
The Expanse – James S.A. Corey – sci-fi factions + conspiracies, multiple POVs actually collide and you see the tension and consequences play out in detail