Books like Apple TV’s Widow’s Bay

I’m enamored with the trailers for “Widow’s Bay” on Apple TV. The supernatural/detective thriller set in coastal New England setting looks terrifying with some clever comedy mixed in. The only problem is I hate watching scary movies and TV (mostly because of jump scares.) So what books should I read instead?

I’ve read a lot of Tana French and also loved The Watchers by A.M. Shine.