Having trouble finding my niche

I keep bouncing off things that should be a "hit" for me, based on other things I've enjoyed. I'll list what I liked/ didn't like.

5 stars:

Earthlings – Sayaka Murata (and everything else she's written)

Boy Parts – Eliza Clark

Paradise Rot – Jenny Hval

Hunchback – Saou Ichikawa

The Vegetarian – Han Kang

Hooked & Butter – Asako Yuzuki

Natural Beauty – Ling Ling Huang

Sky Daddy – Kate Folk

Jillian – Halle Butler

Heaven – Mieko Kawakami

Severance – Ling Ma

DNF

A Good Person – Kirsten King

Yesteryear – Caro Claire Burke

I Who Have Never Known Men – Jaqueline Harpman

Chlorine – Jade Song

Cursed Bunny – Bora Chung

Hurricane Season – Fernanda Melchor

Finished but didn't like:

The Coin – Yasmin Zaher

Diary of a Void – Emi Yagi

Assembly – Natasha Brown

Pick a Colour – Souvankham Thammavongsa

Eileen & MYORR by Ottessa Moshfegh

Molka – Monika Kim